Episodes

Browse all episodes. Listen and learn more.

Episodes

Episode 20: The Reckoning

In the season finale, Maggie give David a chance to explain what happened when Danny and John visited and the guys make a decision on...

Episode 19: The Circling

The team finally gets to speak with David Thorne himself and ask him about everything they've learned. However, the answers were not what...

Episode 18: The Choir Boy

After speaking with Joe Wilkes, the team reckons with the possibility that David could have been involved after all. Do you have...

Episode 17: The Visit

Maggie, John, and Danny finally get to speak with Joe Wilkes...and what he had to say was shocking. His story gets even more complicated...

Episode 16: The Best Friend

Maggie, John, and Danny search for Joe Wilkes' best friend who he allegedly confessed to that he killed Yvonne. Things take a turn to...

Episode 15: The Star Witness

Back on the ground in Ohio, Maggie and the guys continue their search for Chris Campbell. Chris and his girlfriend Rose say the night of...

Episode 14: The Cops

This week Maggie flips the script and turns the microscope on the cops. Who were the detectives in charge of the investigation? Maggie...

Episode 13: The Expert

Veteran forensic expert Karen Smith joins Maggie to look at the crime scene and give her opinion on who could have done this and how....

Episode 12: The Shakedown

In order to understand a murder like this, you have to understand the victim. Maggie, John and Danny talk to some of the people closest...

Episode 11: The Others

Maggie, John and Danny set out in Ohio to speak with some top people of interest who have been named in the case. Jim, the allegedly...

Episode 10: Live from Alliance

Live from Alliance Ohio, Maggie joins John, Danny, Jason, and Sue to answer all of your questions about the wrongful conviction of David...

Episode 9: The PIs

Jason Baldwin from the West Memphis 3 and his team of private investigators from Proclaim Justice team up with Maggie to look into...

Episode 8: The Psychic

Months into the investigation of Yvonne Layne's murder, police felt stuck, so they did something controversial: they went to a psychic....

Episode 7: The Witness

On April 1, 1999, the day Yvonne was found murdered in her home, a neighbor stopped by and told police he saw someone leaving her home,...

Episode 6: The Wife

After David Thorne and Joe Wilkes were arrested for the murder of Yvonne Layne in April 1999, they went to trial in January 2000. What...

Episode 5: The Trial

After David Thorne and Joe Wilkes were arrested for the murder of Yvonne Layne in April 1999, they went to trial in January 2000. What...

Episode 4: The Accomplice

Three months after Yvonne's murder, Joseph Wilkes confessed. He said David Thorne hired him to kill his ex-girlfriend. So who is Joseph...

Episode 3: The Murder

On the morning of April Fools day 1999, Tawnia Layne went to pick up her grandkids at Yvonne's home. But instead, she stumbled upon a...

Episode 2: The Lovers

In this episode we learn about Yvonne, David and how the two came together and had their son, Brandon. But we also learn about the...

Episode 1: Dead in the Water

In 1999, 26-year-old Yvonne Layne was found murdered in her Ohio home while her children slept. Her ex-boyfriend, David Thorne, was...